Review: Attica


Inmates riot, capture guards (one dies), close down the prison and demand better treatment. Is this going to end well?

For five days in September 1971 in upper state New York, 1,281 out of the approximately 2,200 prisoners at Attica Correctional Facility took an amazing risk – a take-over of the prison. During the rebellion, they took 42 prison staff members hostage. Some were injured and one later died from injuries sustained.

After the initial riotous hours, the prisoners gathered in peaceful assembly in the great courtyard where those who had served in Vietnam taught the others how to pitch makeshift tents with poles and sheets and how to dig a latrine trench. Observers and the press were summoned to witness the inmates’ demands.

Somewhere, somehow, these men had hopes. Maybe they were emboldened by the marches for civil rights and demonstrations against the Vietnam War. Maybe they had been emboldened by a literacy in the US Constitution and the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Or maybe they were emboldened by the growing prisoner activism in other facilities. But in fomenting a riot, injuring prison guards and taking over part of a prison they must have forgotten that they were still captives in a punitive system.

The theme for 1971, under President Nixon and the Republican Party, was law and order. A heavy hand smashed on those who did not obey US policy, whether abroad or at home, whether bombing and burning southeast Asia to the ground or dehumanizing the convicted inmates in the US criminal justice system.

In America, the big reason anyone is sent to prison is for punishment and to keep society safe. This isn’t Denmark or Norway where human rights, decency and respect are given to humans no matter what their transgression. The US claims of rehabilitation through training and educational support are a far cry from the mental health, vocational education and reintegration programs offered to Norway’s prison population where their goals include comfort, healing, and inclusivity.

The Attica prisoners had 33 demands, including better medical treatment, fair visitation rights, improved food quality, religious freedom, higher wages for inmate jobs, and an end to physical abuse.

“Attica” is on the Oscar short list for Best Documentary for 2021. Just the editing alone, capturing archival videos and photographs through time, must have taken months. The testimony of the ex-inmates who had been part of the riot explains how the occupation ended. It also encourages the viewer to re-think the American penal system and encourage Congress to develop a much better plan.

ShowTime offers “Attica” for free, during Black History Month at


Directors/Producers: Traci Curry and Stanley Nelson
Writer: Stanley Nelson
Executive Producers: Vinnie Malhotra, Marcia Smith and Jihan Robinson
Editor: Aljernon Tunsil
Co-Editor: Jaclyn Lee
Co-Producer: Sushana Dubriel
Featuring: John Johnson, Daniel Shepherd, Herman Schwartz, Clarence B. Jones, The Valone Family, Daniel Calaghan, George Che Nieves, Elliott James “L.D.” Barkley, and others
Music: Maryam Battaglia
Release: Nov. 6, 2021 (Showtime Premier)

. . .

Join us on Facebook at!

Comments are closed.