Under Review: ‘Atlas Shrugged: Part I’


“Atlas Shrugged: Part I” was a movie very long in the making; not necessarily in the amount of time it took to shoot, but in the history behind the story.

Ayn Rand first published “Atlas Shrugged” — her fourth and final novel — in 1957. Rand considered it her greatest work in the realm of science fiction. Over the past 50-plus years, Rand’s novel has been a hot topic of debate between its many admirers and detractors.

There have been many adaptations in the works for decades, but over the years they all fell through for one reason or another. But now, with help from The Strike Productions and Rocky Mountain Pictures, we all have a chance to see this great work in theaters. Directed by Paul Johansson and with the screenplay written by Brian Patrick O’Toole as well as John Aglialoro, we have a top-notch team assembling a very complex story.

“Atlas Shrugged: Part I” is the first in a planned trilogy of movies, split into three parts just like the book. Part I weaves a tale of a not-so-distant dystopian United States. It’s 2016 and there are oil and gas shortages worldwide. There are international conflicts raging. With the price of gas being more than $30 a gallon, railroads and trains are the only affordable way to travel in a faltering economy. There are few independent corporations thriving outside of the ones endorsed by the government.

Taggart Transcontinental is one of those companies. It’s run by brother and sister duo James Taggart (Matthew Marsden) and Dagny Taggart (Taylor Schilling), who couldn’t be more different from each other. James has his own interests at heart and doesn’t care to do all of the work to keep the company going, while Dagny is busy finding alternative ways to keep the railways in proper working order. She goes to Hank Rearden (Grant Bowler), owner of Rearden Steel, to get the vital replacement railing she needs to get their line in Colorado working again. Dagny chooses to trust in Rearden’s new alloy, called Rearden Metal, which is a lighter and stronger metal than any other on Earth.

With jealousy rising among competitors, Rearden chooses to keep the formula to this new metal a secret and that makes him many enemies. With all of the cards stacking against them and the threat of government intervention looming, they make another ally in Ellis Wyatt (Graham Beckel), sole founder of the Wyatt Oil enterprise and the three of them are off on a quest to make history. Meanwhile, behind the scenes, there are many meetings by major players in the government and private corporations, all set to do what it takes to stop production of Rearden Metal and the rebuilding of the Colorado railroad by Taggart Transcontinental.

Taking a book that has amassed a growing popularity ever since it was first published and changing the setting from the 1950s to 2016 was a risky move, but it paid off in a big way. Setting it in our near future has re-established the story’s sense of importance. Although trains and railroads don’t seem as essential as they may have in the ’50s, it makes sense that they would be the logical choice for transportation if this alternate future reality were to occur.

And whether you are a believer or a skeptic in Ayn Rand’s philosophies and political views, it would be nearly impossible to deny that “Atlas Shrugged: Part I” is a moving and disturbingly-compelling film. With all of the chaos going on in this world, every trip across the United States serves as a reminder of the beauty of this country. With sweeping wide shots of many great states, you get a wave of beauty and hope. This cannot be denied.

The cast of actors assembled to bring this intellectually-stimulating story to life is impressive, with top-notch performances that move you. Taylor Schilling as Dagny Taggart is perfectly cast as a strong and independent woman — you believe in her performance as a renegade business woman among those who are willing to go with the flow. Grant Bowler as Hank Rearden is equally as impressive and is the flawless counterpart to Taylor Schilling’s Dagny. We have very few “good guys” in this film, but Graham Beckel and Edi Gathegi offer wonderful performances in their limited screen time.

Then, as is typical with a story about underdogs, we have a slew of actors portraying the antagonists, giving our hero and heroine problems. First among them is Matthew Marsden as James Taggart, the brother who isn’t seen as evil, more so egocentric and selfish in the way he handles situations. I personally didn’t hate the character, but I can see him growing into much more of a menace as the story progresses. Then, as the businessman out to betray Dagny and Hank, we have Patrick Fischler, a man out to see his own desires met, even if it involves betrayal. The film also stars Jsu Garcia, Michael Lerner, Nick Cassavetes, Ethan Cohn, Rebecca Wisocky, Neill Barry, Christina Pickles, Michael O’Keefe, Geoff Pierson and Armin Shimerman, with each contributing positively to the movie.

In addition, the score — by Elia Cmiral — added a great deal to the film. With just the right amount of danger and beauty in it, the music moves your emotions in tune with what’s happening in the story and truly provides the necessary pump of adrenaline necessary for any good thriller. Some people don’t notice things like music, and sometimes I don’t as much either, but when it is a truly great addition to any film, I cannot ignore it.

On the whole, I can imagine how difficult it must have been to condense a third of this massive book into a movie — it was difficult enough to do so in this review. This is a complex and intellectual movie that has many different plots and subplots involved, but I was able to keep pace with the movie and take it all in. Just like with last year’s “Inception,” this movie and story has multiple layers to it; there are many subplots and immense amounts of characters all with their own agendas. This film could be watched multiple times, uncovering new pieces each time.

Whether you have read the book or not, see yourself as a political intellectual or even just a fan of thrilling dramas, you are sure to enjoy the ride “Atlas Shrugged: Part I” takes you on. The fact that it has current importance to our society and where we could be heading is just another reason why I suggest you head out to your local theaters and participate in the experience that is “Atlas Shrugged: Part I.”

“Atlas Shrugged: Part I” opens in theaters April 15 and is rated PG-13 for sexuality.

. . .

Follow Adam Poynter on Twitter at

And don’t forget to “Like” It’s Just Movies on Facebook at

20 Comments Add Yours ↓

  1. Geraldine #

    Wow! Sounds like a very interesting movie. I’m definitely gonna have to go see it when it comes out.

  2. Juliet #

    Insightful review, I am really looking forward to seeing the movie. I love scifi and can’t wait to hear the music that goes with it. I feel that even though I had never heard of the book before now, I won’t be lost when I watch the movie.

  3. Bryan #

    I was concerned that the material was going to be too daunting to convert for the screen. I’m looking forward to seeing the adaptation as I truly enjoyed the book.

  4. Jamie #

    I read your review and then went ahead and looked to see if I could find a trailer. WOW. This looks like a really good movie. I can’t wait to see the movie and can only hope that the sequels are as good and pull the whole story together.

  5. Albert #

    I will say that Ive never heard of the book before but am now kind of interested in checking it out. If the movie is as good as you say I’m sure it will be quite a success.

  6. Phil the Tiger #

    Loved the book and I’m cautiously optimistic about this.

  7. 7

    Thanks for the summary/review. I hope the moral dilemmas were brought to life, too, in addition to the political ones.

    Looking forward to seeing it.

  8. 8

    Atlas Shrugged is my favorite book and I have been anxiously awaiting the movie and of course seeing the trailer and the other scenes that they have shown are excellent. April 15, 2011 is coming quickly so we do not have long to wait.

    I think it is funny that Graham Beckel who plays Ellis Wyatt is the brother of Bob Beckel who of course ia a big progressive commentator and former Jimmy Carter aide. Must be tough watching his brother in a movie that shows the ills of progressivism.

  9. 9

    I’ve been worried about this–will the movie lose the novel’s power and scope? Might it even sell out the story’s principles? This review gives me more hope that the film will be as good as it should be, and worthy of Rand’s classic.

  10. rjwebster10 #

    Absolutely can’t wait to see the movie. For what it’s worth, you guys should make the screenshot with the Galt Line passing over the Rearden Bridge a high-def computer background.

  11. Brenda Bradshaw #

    I am with Phil the Tiger. It is my favorite book of all time and I had already “cast” the main characters in my mind. I sure hope they do justice to the book – which is beyond equal. Disturbingly, I have heard that a lot of cities/movie chains won’t be showing the movie. What are they afraid of? That people might actually wake up and really see what is going on in the world around them?

  12. R. Cameron #

    While I enjoyed your review, I belive that there are a couple of [philisophical] errors that I am quite certain Ayn Rand would have disapproved of. First when you mentioned that “James has his own interests at heart” I do not think that Ms. Rand would agree. It would be more accurate to say that James does not understand what his own interests are – let alone how to achieve them. He strives for the respect of being a producer and is unwilling to exert the effort required to achieve the desired result. Also, later in the review you reference James Taggart as being selfish – in the novel the fatal flaw of this character is the exact opposite. Without Dagney’s “selfish” actions the railroad would swiftly collapse. It is important to understand the definition and context in which Ms. Rand uses the words selfish and selfless. I am very excited to see the movie and hope that it will inspire more to read the book. Thank you for the review.

  13. Susan #

    First, I agree with R. Cameron’s take on the true nature and character of James Taggart. Right on.

    Secondly, I CAN’T WAIT for the release of the film. Like others, I remain cautiously optimistic. This review has given me great hope that the film will not disappoint. I’m glad it’s being made into a trilogy in keeping with the 3 parts of the novel. It would have been impossible to capture it all in one film.

    As for adaptation, I think it was appropriate to set the timing towards the future in light of what we are seeing transpire in America today. People need to see the relevance that such issues bear on their life here and now, before it’s too late.

  14. Lia #

    Thanks for your review!
    Just wanted to mention re: what you wrote about changing the setting that the book is not set in any specific time period so there is no problem placing it anywhere in history.
    Ayn Rand purposefully didn’t mention any specific date (year) a single time in the entire book because she saw the theme and purpose as timeless; as indeed it is. Many of the events she wrote about are happening today! So 1950s, 2010s, 2300s – doesn’t matter 🙂
    For those looking for the trailer and clips, check out “Atlas Shrugged Movie” on youtube and Facebook.

  15. Tom #

    Gave the book to two of my sons for Christmas and just finished re-reading it myself. Gave my copy to my son-in-law to read. As much as I’d like to hope, I don’t see any way the movie could be as good as the book. READ THE BOOK!…then see the movie.

  16. Bob Cusick #

    Who is John Galt?

  17. Bob #

    I have the book but haven’t read it yet. I hope to get through it this week before seeing the movie. The way you describe the movie makes me want to hurry up and read the book.

  18. dorn #

    I am really looking forward to the movie. I agree that Taylor Schilling is perfect casting for Dagny. Sure, if they had more money they could have bought a bigger name, but Taylor’s intensity is perfect for this. It will also be better that she doesn’t have other iconic characters on her resume to cloud the impression.

  19. 19

    Hey thanks for this good review!
    I love how you write that “And whether you are a believer or a skeptic in Ayn Rand’s philosophies and political views, it would be nearly impossible to deny that “Atlas Shrugged: Part I” is a moving and disturbingly-compelling film. ” You nailed it.I watched the film last night in Sandy, UT and love it! I also made a review. Hope it gets more people to go see the film and adds significantly to the buzz.

  20. Dretch #

    This was a terrible, terrible film.

3 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Two Clips from ‘Atlas Shrugged: Part 1′ /  It's Just Movies 18 04 11
  2. A Teaser for Atlas Shrugged: Part 2 /  It's Just Movies 07 02 12
  3. Trailer: Atlas Shrugged: Part II /  It's Just Movies 07 09 12